Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes

Close-up of creamy ivory mashed potatoes topped with a melting pat of butter and chopped chives, with a silver spoon resting in the white serving bowl.

☕🥐🐈🔍

From Piper's Recipe Box

Make-Ahead Mashed Potatoes


The Wednesday job

Prep
30 min
Reheat
40 min
Serves
10–12

Every Thanksgiving has one job that has to be done the day before, and it is this one. Potatoes made on Thursday morning mean somebody is standing at a stove mashing while everything else goes cold, and that somebody is always the same person, and that person would like a turn at the table. So you make them Wednesday. They go in the refrigerator. On Thursday they go in the oven and come out better than they went in, which almost nothing in cooking does.

You'll Need

What To Do

  1. Boil the potatoes in well-salted water until a knife slides through with no argument, 18–20 minutes. Drain them and let them steam dry in the hot pot for a full two minutes — wet potatoes make gluey ones.
  2. Mash them while they're hot, then beat in the cream cheese, sour cream, butter and warm milk. Salt hard. Taste. Salt again, because cold potatoes taste blander than warm ones and these are going in the refrigerator.
  3. Spread into a buttered baking dish, dot the top with more butter, cover tightly, and refrigerate up to two days.
  4. On the day: take them out an hour before, then bake covered at 350°F for 30 minutes, uncover, and give them another 10 until the top is just starting to go gold.

The cream cheese is doing structural work, not flavor work. It's what keeps them from going grainy and sad overnight, which is what happens to plain mashed potatoes in the refrigerator. Don't skip it and don't substitute it.

Piper Page
Recipes from Maplebrook

This one comes out of the Maplebrook Cozy Mysteries, and so does every other recipe on here — there are more in the back of every book in the series.

See all the books →

Next
Next

Overnight Cranberry Orange Sweet Rolls